|Tuesday, 28 November 2023 Home About Us Contact Us|
You are here:
Mail to a Friend Printer friendly
Bursting the Myth that Qutb and Banna Compare to Ibn Hajar and an-Nawawi
From the greatest of signs of the depravity and desperateness of the followers of the secular (non-Islamic) methodologies of al-Ikhwan al-Muslimeen (brought to them by Qutb and Banna from the ideologies, philosophies, doctrines, methodologies and manifestos of secular atheist Jews, Christian philosophers and others) - is that they seek to make excuses for their lords of innovation by comparing them with the great, lofty, mighty and noble Scholars of Islam whose contribution and benefit to the Ummah is truly immense.
The doctrines of these innovators cannot stand on their own grounds and merits. The Scholars of Ahl us-Sunnah have demolished and refuted these foreign, alien methodologies. The Scholars of Ahl us-Sunnah have demonstrated the ignorance of these individuals (speaking with all the major innovations, uttering kufr, attachment to the graves, speaking with Wahdat ul-Wujood, uniting between the Sunnis and Rafidees and so on). So what was left for these people? To compare the contribution of Qutb and Banna to the Ummah to that of Ibn Hajar and Nawawi and to compare the mistakes of Qutb and Banna to those of Ibn Hajar and Nawawi.
In this series we will burst this myth in order to defend the honour of Imaams like Ibn Hajar and an-Nawawi, from them being belittled through comparison with ignoramuses of the 20th century who left nothing but trails of destruction and vile hizbiyyah in the Ummah.
The Contribution of Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani to the Ummah
From an online source: Ibn Hajar authored more than fifty works on hadith, hadith terminology, biographical evaluation, history, Quranic exegesis, poetry and Shafi'i jurisprudence.
Now, stand in front of your Lord, pray two rakahs, then sit and make dhikr for half an hour, then spend the next half hour in striving to rid your soul of all desires, and when you feel you have, answer truthfully and boldly, (don't be a coward) this question:
Did Sayyid Qutb or Hasan al-Banna make a contribution to the Ummah such as this? Or the likes of this. Or one half of this? Or one quarter of this? Or one tenth of this. Or even one-hundredth of this?
And on the basis of the answer that you find in your soul, do you think it is correct for Ibn Hajar to be defamed and belittled by comparing him to 20th century ignoramuses - one of whom caused doubt about the Sunnah in general (see here), and rejected aahaad hadeeth in matters of aqidah ( see here)? And in this moment of honesty, sincerity and truthfulness, do you think that comparing this mountain of knowledge to 20th century ignoramuses who brought the doctrines, ideologies, manifestos and methodologies of secularist atheist Jews, Christians and others, into the Ummah, putting it to trial and tribulation, as well as mocking a Messenger of Allah, reviling the caliph Uthmaan (radiallaahu anhu), accusing the Uncle of the Believers Mu'aawiyah (radiallaahu anhu) of nifaq, ghish, khadee'ah is anything but a fraud of the highest order? Allaah is watching over you and knows your inner thoughts and secrets!
Once, you have spent this hour of honesty and truthfulness, alone with just you and your Lord, then come back to your online cesspit and write and distribute this plain obvious manifest truth, if you are a person who venerates, honours and respects the Sunnah and its people!
We can add here what we mentioned in a previous article:
Ibn Hajar, an-Nawawi: Take out the ta'weels that Ibn Hajr fell into in all of his various works and what are you left with? Tens of thousands of pages of truly beneficial knowledge in a wide range of subjects - in hadeeth, in fiqh, in aqidah, in adab, in mu'aamalah and so on and so on. We have great works such as Fath ul-Bari, and Buloogh ul-Mar'aam and really, this deserves a separate article on its own. Their errors are completely drowned in the mountains and oceans of goodness, which continue to benefit the Muslims in their deen to this day.
Thanks Qutb (and Banna), you really aided the deen and the dunyaa!
And be sure to read this:
Link to this article: Show: HTML Link Full Link Short Link
You must be registered and logged in to comment.